The War on Talk Radio (a New York institution)

"So to argue that what I'm putting in here is a dramatic change of the law, is going to somehow muzzle Rush Limbaugh, it's not the case. What we're suggesting is that it is best that we follow the guidelines already in the law to promote and encourage diversity in media ownership."
-- Illinois Senator Dick Durbin

This is not an effort to muzzle Rush Limbaugh? Gimme a break!

The war on (conservative) talk radio has just begun. The Fairness Doctrine was voted down in the Senate; that would have required some "talk police" to balance every conservative and liberal statement 50-50. However, Senator Dick Durbin's "diversity" proposal passed. In practice, it will be even more destructive of conservative talk radio--Durbin's one true aim.

Talk radio began in New York City. Barry Gray (1916-1996) began his talk on WMCA in the late 1940s, at Chandler's restaurant on East 46th Street. No plaque today honors New York City's past.

New York has talk ("all" or "some") stations such as WABC, WOR,WNYC, WMCA, WBAI, WPAT, WLIB, WFAN, and more.

There are no diversity barriers to entry in the New York City market. If Oprah wants to buy a radio station here (or anywhere), she could. If Michael Bloomberg wants to buy a radio station, he could. (Bloomberg Inc. already has some media outlets.) If Air America wants to buy a radio station, it could. But no one wants to listen to Mark Green!

There are no existing problems that require government intervention.

It's true that Rush Limbaugh has been highly successful. If you like him, you can tune in. If you don't like him, you don't listen. In America, we usually value someone who succeeds in the free market.

Senator Dick Durbin's attempt to muzzle Rush Limbaugh is through "diversity" and "localism" rules. The station that carries Limbaugh (WABC) also has local hosts, such as Curtis Sliwa. The owners of WABC might be black or white--no one should care. 

WFAN is devoted to sports talk. It doesn't talk a lot--if at all--about girls high school basketball in Staten Island. Nor should it, if people don't want to listen to that.

The local politicians in New York City are almost all Democrats.  If local radio rules and "diversity" were left up to the likes of Christine Quinn, you can bet that some objection will be made about Rush Limbaugh being on New York City's airwaves. How dare a Conservative speak in Democratic New York!

Buried in the Bill of Rights in the First Amendment to the Constitution is something called "freedom of speech."

Dick Durbin seeks to regulate it, at our peril.

LINKS:

http://www.rushlimbaugh.com/home/daily/site_022609/content/01125112.guest.html

Dick Durbin Introduces Backdoor Attempt at the Fairness Doctrine
February 26, 2009

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk_radio

Talk radio as a listener-participation format has existed since at least the mid-1940s. Working for New York's WMCA in 1945, Barry Gray was bored with playing music and put a telephone receiver up to his microphone to talk with bandleader Woody Herman. Soon followed by listener call-ins, this is often credited as the first instance of talk radio, and Gray is often billed as "The hot mama of Talk Radio."

http://www.barrypopik.com/index.php/new_york_city/entry/talk_radio/



Gatemouth's picture
Submitted by Gatemouth on Fri, 02/27/2009 - 7:03am.

Though I suspect 20 years from now, it may be less relevant, boradcast radio and tV are harly a free market. Frequencies are not, like ink and paper, unlimited resources. They are a scarce commodity in which the government has some discretion and gets to set some rules to facilitate some goals. I can set up a printing press in my basement, but not a radio station. If I do, I can be jailed for stomping on someone else's frequency

That being said, I'm not sure reinstating the fairness doctrine really serves any useful pupose. The olden were really not so Golden, and more importantly, cable and satellite will eventually render the scarcity a lot less relevant. But the idea that this is a liberal attempt to trample free speech and the unregulated market of ideas is just so much fertlizer.



Submitted by Barry Popik on Fri, 02/27/2009 - 2:02pm.

New York Senator Chuck Schumer clearly stated the intent of such regulations just a few months ago.

http://michellemalkin.com/2008/11/04/fairness-doctrine-watch-schumer-likes-conservative-opinion-to-pornography/

Fairness Doctrine Watch:

Schumer likens conservative opinion to pornography

By Michelle Malkin  •  November 4, 2008 11:01 AM
Lots of readers have been alerting me to Chuck Schumer’s comments on Fox News this morning, reportedly comparing conservative opinion to pornography that needs to be regulated. Fairness Doctrine here we come.

Submitted by Critical Thinker (not verified) on Sat, 02/28/2009 - 8:57am.

If the feds would mandate critical thinking skills in K-12 as required curriculum, we wouldn't need "radio police" because the likes of Rush Linbaugh would be laughed off the airways.

I applaud DIck Durbin's effort to control "pulpit politics" which inflames the undereducated emotions and sensibilities that frequent the airways polluted by Linbaugh's and Pat Robertson's inflammatory rhetoric, based on religiously inspired dogma.

This country was founded on the premise of separation of church and state, but Limbaugh and Robertson and their cohorts would have their purported christial beleives legislated, so that no freedom of thought could co-exist with their views.

Case in point, one Texas town wanted to outlaw Darwin's theory in the public school curriculum. How outrageous can they get? 

Schizophrenia Symptoms | Amlodipine Besylate
Gatemouth's picture
Submitted by Gatemouth on Sat, 02/28/2009 - 10:42am.

Airwaves are not like a newspaper. They are a scare commodity, which the government has allocated to serve public purposes, creating millionaires in the process. Given that this is the case, the idea that we have an unbridled free market place here is just so much nonsense. No one has an unbridled right to use a scarce resource they were allocated as a government franchose for their own unregulated purposes. If they didn't want to be subjected to such restrictions, they should have put out a magazine instead.

That being said, this is becoming less and less true every day. Broadcast TV is almost irrelevant, and broadcast radio will soon go down the same path. Thus both efforts to enforce "fairness" and whining about such efforts will soon go the way of the vinyl LP and compassionate conservatism.



Submitted by Larry Littlefield on Sun, 03/01/2009 - 2:16pm.
"At a quarter to three, he climbs out of his tree, for the..."

My cousin was a fan. He loved it when you know who used to curse callers out in Italian.

Submitted by heidan on Sat, 11/26/2011 - 2:15am.

Doudoune Moncler Femme In the real into after repeating it back on the right track, will be one of the beautiful feather appear delicate the today, in the field of eider down.Doudoune Moncler Homme series of outdoor activities to more time for customers providing Let's moncler together fashion brands and product information, so that kept the mouth becoming a second-tier cities, fashion backbone.Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher Japan, Germany, Australia, Switzerland, United Kingdom, Sweden, Norway, Denmark or exercise those boutiques boutique shop to buymoncler well-known things.


Submitted by heidan on Sat, 11/26/2011 - 2:15am.

Doudoune Moncler continues to open boutique doors in new markets outside of europe,designed by the gilles,& boissier architecture studio.Moncler costruire pi�� forza nel 1999 ha portato come un campo di direttore creativo mostrare Remo Ruffini prima - 2000 la primavera e l'estate della serie.


Submitted by canada goose outlet on Sat, 11/26/2011 - 7:58am.
The North Face Outlet Denali Fleece Jacket_Grey from the north face outlet are designed for women’s outdoor activities for winter. With perfect and humanized design, they are easy outdoor events. These North Face Sales women jackets for cheap are great on movement with multi-functional. Breathable, durable, functional, the products of The North Face Jackets for women are always worth to pay. Coming with rich colors and styles, these The North Face Outlet women jackets are on big now!
Submitted by canada goose outlet on Sat, 11/26/2011 - 7:59am.
Moncler Outlet most certainly an stylish fashion which may focuses primarily on back garden sportswear.It creates outstanding sportswear on the internet.Must you gear the right match of soothing and chic budget Moncler Jackets vital that you do not lose one most comfortable on top of that sizzling hot moncler bottes.Stay with this guidance position " booties " in order to complement from Moncler apparel should help your fashional preferences. Moncler Outlet
Submitted by heidan on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 8:24pm.
Moncler non troverete che yourjackets sar�� scaduto la prossima stagione. qual �� la moda secondo voi? ti piace seguire la moda?Piumini Moncler Una medicazione bel guardare ti fa guardare distintivo e inimitabile,Tutto ci�� pu�� dipendere da Moncler.
Submitted by heidan on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 8:25pm.
Moncler ha recentemente annunciato due nuove collezioni. VISVIM di Hiroki Nakamura �� responsabile della presa di da uomo.Piumini Moncler sono disponibili in diversi modelli e caratteristiche,Le giacche sono dotati di cappe e che rispecchiano una linea di abbigliamento casual.
Submitted by Anonymousd (not verified) on Wed, 11/30/2011 - 11:07pm.
Submitted by dnymous (not verified) on Mon, 12/05/2011 - 3:39am.
Submitted by tanisha gerstein (not verified) on Wed, 12/14/2011 - 6:14am.
Seems like some shuck and jive going down by the "Progressive" Left. In other words, the headline of Fairness Doctrine being revoked was declawed by the "Turban" Durbin amendment. The door is open for something similar to it, under a different guise to be inflicted on the airwaves. This did not show up in the major media outlets because of their ritalin riddled brains with a lack of patience to read through the entire bill. This is part of the same bill. No surprise - pretty much as I predicted. 2011 christmas gifts top gifts 2011
Submitted by lancelBB on Sat, 12/17/2011 - 7:00am.
Le

sac lancel

peut être très coûteux, mais ce n'est pas surprenant compte tenu des matériaux utilisés fines et une excellente qualité du produit. Cependant, nous ne pouvons pas aider mais essayer de chercher de bonnes affaires. Les bonnes nouvelles sont que vous pouvez obtenir de maroquinerie lancel solde véritables de la vente de liquidation à bas prix. Vous pouvez vendre ces produits à des prix réduits et encore faire un profit énorme. Avez-vous jamais demandé comment certains propriétaires d'entreprises peuvent vendre des vente alcantara sac a main pas cher produits griffés à des prix réduits? Il est tout simplement une question de trouver des fournisseurs qui peuvent fournir des sac miss lancel à faible prix de gros. Par exemple, Lancel a une liste de cas ou des liquidateurs vendent des palettes de sacs à main designer authentique. Vous pouvez généralement obtenir les produits à 70% de rabais sur le prix de détail, vous donnant beaucoup de place pour votre marge de profit. vente privée sac de la vente de liquidation proviennent généralement de grands magasins qui sont l'élimination de leurs stocks pour une raison ou une l'autre. Il est possible que le magasin du

sac à main lancel

va fermer ou de déplacer vers un autre emplacement. Peut-être qu'ils veulent vider leurs stocks anciens pour faire place à de nouvelles. http://www.ventesprivees-sacs.com/
Submitted by ericka keppler (not verified) on Wed, 12/28/2011 - 2:00pm.
Estoy impresionado, tengo que decir. Muy rara vez tengo que encontrar un blog que es igualmente educativo y entretenido, y bien, te diré, que ha dado en el clavo en la cabeza. Su idea es realmente excelente, el asunto es algo que la gente está hablando insuficiente inteligentemente sobre.
Online Backup Review

Submitted by machen on Sun, 01/29/2012 - 8:59pm.
Trp to AVI Converterkuten MP4, FLV, AVI, ASF, WMV, 3GP, MOV, M4V, MPG, WMV, sekä kaikki äänitiedostojen myös m4a, mp3, ac3, aac, wma, wav, ogg, ape.Trp to WMV ConverterSen avulla on rikas vaihtoehtoja säätää videon asetuksia ja asettaa ääniominaisuudet,
Trp to MOV Converterkuten audio bitrate, näytteenottotaajuus,
Submitted by mincir du ventre rapidement (not verified) on Tue, 01/31/2012 - 10:10am.
Dead pent content material, appreciate it for entropy.
Submitted by mincir vite (not verified) on Sat, 02/04/2012 - 3:11am.
I am glad to be a visitor of this arrant web site, thank you for this rare information!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.