Raoul Felder Gets Censure for "Schmucks"
Wow. I'm not sure how widely this has been disseminated (.pdf) yet, but the state's Commission on Judicial Conduct just issued a statement of no confidence in its chairman, Raoul Felder -- also known as, among other things, Rudy Giuliani's divorce lawyer.
The statement -- unanimous, minus Felder -- was triggered by Felder's new book, called "Schmucks". From the statement: The Commission’s loss of confidence in Mr. Felder’s judgment is rooted in a book he recently co-authored.3 Much of the material in this book, and the work as a whole, undermine the appearance of impartiality, and the dignity and probity that is required of the Commission and its Chair. Although the book purports to be a work of humor, much of it is crude, biased, vulgar and otherwise demeaning. For example, we note the following.
• The book repeatedly invokes racial, ethnic and religious invective. Such statements are inconsistent with the Commission’s role in enforcing the judicial obligations to refrain from words or conduct that manifest bias based on race, religion or national origin, and to require court employees and lawyers to refrain from such conduct.4 • The book asserts that “anytime you hear the word ‘allegedly,’ you can bet it’s true.”5 Such a viewpoint is untenable from a Commission member whose role is to evaluate allegations of judicial misconduct and identify those that have merit. • The book claims that “nothing in our country is more insidious than affirmative action.”6 Such a sentiment raises a reasonable perception that the speaker could not pass fair judgment on anyone he perceived to have benefited from affirmative action.
Post new comment |