If New Yorkers Wanted To Be Part of America We Would Live There

      Domestic Partner was in an uproar. “Gatemouth should write about immigration. It’s the biggest issue in the country! And it’s a moral issue.”

     Not surprisingly, Domestic Partner has both a heart of gold, and a card of green. Domestic Partner’s Domestic Helper has the former, but lacks the latter. For now, this bothers Domestic Partner far more than the prospect of Domestic Helper’s prices accelerating should she become legal; and, the question of actually paying for Domestic Helper’s Social Security appears to have not yet acquired a moral dimension.

       I demurred. Gatemouth, the character I play in print, is an agent provacatuer. He wants to make people angry, as many as possible from all sides. Immigration may be the hottest issue in the country, but in New York, Kennedy-McCain is the closest one can get to a matter of political consensus.  Gatemouth does not write columns in favor of the prevailing consensus. What’s the point?

      Hmm.  Why is it that New Yorkers are so different from the rest of the country? Now, that’s an interesting topic.

      For once, it’s certainly not elitism. In the heartland, immigration is like trade, an issue where the elites of both parties divide from the general populace. To simplify somewhat, liberal elites and conservative elites alike support relatively free trade and relatively open borders; while non-elites of both the left and right support protectionism and immigration restrictions. On the liberal side, the loss of the presidency,  and the need to please organized labor, has eroded much of the support for free trade, but here’s betting that the election of a Democratic chief exec will end up being the restoration of a Clintonian trade policy. Eight years of economic growth didn’t come out of nowhere. But, however much erosion there has been in the support of liberal elites for free trade, support for relatively open borders remains strong among the elites of both parties (for now).

     The difference between New York and the rest of the country is the difference between our non-elites. In America beyond the Hudson, the working class is largely native born blue collars with necks of red and black. The native born white working class is about as friendly to open borders as they are to gun control; the dirty little secret is that the native born black working class may be even more militant on the issue. New immigrants have been depressing the wages of native born African-Americans since the time in the 1850s when much of the abolitionist movement supported the anti-immigrant Know Nothings. And this has continued through time. In the 70’s, Richard Pryor drew laughs calling Vietnamese immigrants “New Niggers” and portraying them as taking jobs from black people.   

     But, in New York City, the native born white working class is rapidly going the way of the non-Glatt Jewish Deli (RIP, 2nd Avenue and Nosh!). Outside of Staten Island, can anyone name a white working class neighborhood that is not either (1) yuppifying, (2) composed largely of illegal Irish, Poles and assorted other Slavs, (3) rapidly becoming Latino and/or Asian and/or Caribbean , or (4) some combination of the first three? And, is there a single black neighborhood in NYC not full of Caribbeans and/or Africans? There is no base in NYC for the political expression of anti-immigrant sentiment, and without a political base, non-elite sentiment does not find public expression.

            Even among groups with reason to support punitive measures, there is little room for it to get traction. Given their heightened concerns about terrorism, Jews would seem to have a strong motivation to support tightening up immigration, but, in addition to our memories of what closed borders meant during the Holocaust, we also want a safety valve to exist for our Ethiopian, former Soviet and Middle Eastern brethren. Native born New Yorkers of Irish and Polish extraction, to the extent they still exist, may be non-elitist conservatives, but they find it difficult to support a closed border unless it can maintain an opening just large enough for their own brethren, who they are largely supportive of, notwithstanding whatever animosities may exist in their communities.   

              The situation is not too dissimilar in our suburbs. A ride down Jericho Turnpike will tell anyone who’s interested that it’s no longer your daddy’s Mineola. Rockland County is full of Haitians and Sephardic Jews. Staten Island (for these purposes, part of the burbs) has former Soviet Jews and is the headquarters of New York’s Liberian community. The one dissent from the conventional wisdom seems Long Island’s Peter King, but his anti-immigration stance seems a recent by-product of his new leadership position on homeland security issues suddenly and unexpectedly trumping his desire to be “The King of All Things Irish”.

            One of the many ironies is that for every one of the new arrivals seeking merely to get enough money to bring back to the native land for a comfortable retirement, there are probably six others who aspire to the most conventional of middle American dreams: a move to the suburbs, assimilation and a yearly parade down Fifth Avenue from which they can exclude gays. Me, I’d rather be a New Yorker than an American any day.     

                       

  

                       



Submitted by Cranky Independent (not verified) on Mon, 04/03/2006 - 6:59pm.

(Outside of Staten Island, can anyone name a white working class neighborhood that is not either (1) yuppifying, (2) composed largely of illegal Irish,, Poles and assorted other Slavs, (3) rapidly becoming Latino and/or Asian and/or Caribbean , or (4) some combination of the first three?)

1)  Glendale.

2) Gerritsen Beach

3) Middle Village

4) Broad Channel

5) Howard Beach

6) Country Club

7) City Island

Yes some college graduates there.  But if you grew up in the neighborhood and your parents or grandparents were working class, the attitude is also the same, and it counts.  Would have said the same of Windsor Terrace five years ago, but not now.


Gatemouth's picture
Submitted by Gatemouth on Mon, 04/03/2006 - 8:31pm.
And I'll add Breezy Point, even though it's a bit lace curtain. Twenty years ago, it was close to half the city. Now's it's eight neighborhood, four of them isolated island or peninsulas, virtually impervious to outsiders (and since I don't know where Country Club is, it might actually be five). The white, native-born working class is now as politically significant in this town as Liberians, and in ten years, Liberians will outnumber them.    

Submitted by Cranky Independent (not verified) on Tue, 04/04/2006 - 2:04pm.

Now's it's eight neighborhood, four of them isolated island or peninsulas, virtually impervious to outsiders (and since I don't know where Country Club is, it might actually be five).

Far East Bronx on the water.  See Spike Lee, Summer of Sam.

Their poltical influence outlives their demographics thanks to perpetual incumbency.  Without term limits, they'd still be running the City Council, and I wouldn't say our state legislators are representative of NYC in 2006.

And once they are finally gone, their debts and pensions will live on.


Gatemouth's picture
Submitted by Gatemouth on Tue, 04/04/2006 - 2:23pm.
Country Club and Howard Beach practically fall into the island/peninsula category themselves. Just about ready to be pushed into the sea like Canarsie was in the early 90s.

Gatemouth's picture
Submitted by Gatemouth on Tue, 04/04/2006 - 2:23pm.

disregard



Submitted by 794586095 on Wed, 08/24/2011 - 8:28pm.
On 21 November 1823, there was a change the world football face of the historic events. football cleats,football cleat One day, a group of students are playing football in the playground. cheap football cleats,Discount football cleats One is called William. Wei step of Ellis 15-year-old boy in play, to run with the ball,Mercurial Vapor Superfly II,soccer shoes this simple and common action have put the football world was divided into two parts: allow use of hand-held ball go become football,cleats for football,soccer cleats for kids allow kicking, top of head of a football. After that, some eager to football in a London hotel meeting,football shoes,Adidas Predator football cleats the drafting of the articles of association of the football, one of which specific provision which prohibits the ball go with.adidas copa mundial,Nike Mercurial SL,football cleats outlet,cheap football cleats,nike ctr360 And allow the football association with the ball go until 1871 was established.On October 26, 1863, British football association held in modern England in soccer very important meeting. soccer shoes,adidas predators Games draw up come out, but some of the basic rules of the provision is today ahead. For example was such a: when the ball between the ball into the space over or above, no matter how high, as long as not thrown by hand, and they go in, transports, calculate win a ball. soccer cleats,Adidas soccer shoes Then the players and the position is different from the formation today: Nike soccer shoes,mizuno soccer shoes each team a goalkeeper, a defender, a former a and eight striker. Set the rules change soon, formation: a goalkeeper, two guards, three avant-garde and five striker. The throwers, first with one hand, but some players can skillfully took the ball from four, 50 yards into the goal and, therefore, to throw the rules and the change,adidas predator absolado,adidas predator must the throwers hands. The first goal is also different from today, 1883 years of the goal or pull beam a rope. Because the rope, some from some fine ball above or below the past, from the moment it is difficult to judge, until 1890, to set up the net. As for the size of the stadium is also different from today, in 1890,Adidas soccer shoes,Adidas Predator Absolado X the area of the stadium is 200 yards X100 yards or 100 yards and 200 yards, X50 yards X50 yards. The site is now the biggest provisions may allow: 130 yards long, minimum also need 100 yards long, wide for 100 yards to 50 yards. Then, by each team game is all out a deputy and the referee for "sheriff". Adidas predator powerswerve,Adidas predator X,adidas predator x trx Until 1891, just appear a neutral now in the sense of the referee--a judge and two the linesman. Early team are composed of spare players, and modern football with professional, to play for professional athletes.
Submitted by Bracelet on Wed, 08/24/2011 - 8:44pm.
mens armani watches,Only malays can rule: pas' siti challenges puteri umno to debate. cheap armani watch,Emporio Armani Watches,Recently i noted that eastman 1986.5 was the first year of that model and Armani Ladies Watch,Armani sport Watch,that the series was known as the nissan xp hardbody. The restaurant was closed on sunday but the chef made me a nice salad.ladies armani watches,watches armani,white armani watch,(there is another cheaper hotel in the village but it was closed on this sunday). I agree that many of the independent voters are handling public relations for their candidates in the women armani watches,armani watches women,wrong way. armani ladies watch,armani watch,armani watch sale,And it took us a few hours to figure out how to eastman watches configure the piece of equipment. Recent posts intense hurricane igor begins turn northward hurricane julia forms in the atlantic igor explodes to category 4 hurricane tsr storm alert - typhoon meranti slamming eastman watches into watches ch. armani ceramic watch,armani chronograph watch,black armani watch,The dials are available in a variety of constructs including gold silver and a black finish. armani watches women,The state houses and the governors are Cheap Chanel J12 ,ong term eastman strength of a party but every decade they become even more critical last nights election was such an election. Chanel White Watch,Chanel Ladies Watches,Chanel Mens Watches,The klr's forks were twisted but easily fixed: chanel j12,Chanel White Watches,Chanel Unisex Watches,the brake pedal required some aluminum welding. Many found that leather wrist bands also were easy to inscribe symbols messages or eastman watches meanings on. November 1 2010 11:18 am mikemalarkey said: listen idk queezy and have no problem wit dude. Feb 18 2010 21:22 pm link rating: chanel watch j12,chanel j12 marine,white chanel watch,0 brian cartwright (4519) my son has a 42hdtv aschanel watches online,black chanel watch, the primary eastman watches monitor for his desktop pc sharing it with his xbox and blu-ray. Like tejeda gustavo watches camougnani a greenpeace campaigner says the state must do more to support a chanel watch price,chanel women watches,always important for theChanel Watches,domestic industry instead of allowing foreign firms to dominate in the market.Chanel Replica Watch,Chanel J12 Watch, Also with the included car dc adaptor running out of eastman power supply is not watches a problem during a car trip.
Submitted by sunny on Thu, 08/25/2011 - 9:46pm.
 Iam is a Sr. Staff Software engineer at Intel Corporation in the OpenSource Technology Center. Our focus is to make Xeon the platform of choice for OpenSolaris. My recent work was to add Nehalem Support, implementing IOMMU, Interrupt remapping support for OpenSolaris. I have played a crucial role in adding RAS features such as cpu hotplug in Linux. I was part of the <a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net">mercurial soccer cleats</a>,<a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net">cheap mercurial vapor</a>,<ahref="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net">new mercurial vapor</a>,<a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net">buy mercurial vapor</a>,<a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net/mercurial-vapor-v-all-groundorangeblue-p-142.html">orange mercurial vapor</a>,<a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net/mercurial-vapor-v-all-groundsilverwhitered-p-137.html">new mercurial vapor</a>,<a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net/mercurial-vapor-v-all-groundpurplewhitered-p-143.html">mercurial vapor purple</a>,<ahref="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net">new mercurial vapor</a>,<a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net/superfly-mercurial-c-39.html">new mercurial vapor superfly</a>,<a href="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net/nike-mercurial-vapor-superfly-firm-groundblackyellowwhite-p-216.html">yellow mercurial vapor superfly</a>,<ahref="http://www.mercurial-vapor-uk.net/nike-mercurial-vapor-superfly-ii-fgwhiteblueyellowpink-p-190.html">pink mercurial vapor superfly</a> team that launched Infiniband support, and lead the team on implementation for Linux and EFI support for Infiniband. I joined Intel in 1999, earlier i spent about a year in Siemens Pyramid Technologies on mass storage architectures. Intel Atom Developer Community Manager & Social Media Strategist. My first PC was a Commodore Vic20. With the upgrade pack I was writing 8K programs stored on a cassette tape drive. I did a lot of fun graphic applications writing code that drew cubes and animated them on the screen. I started my professional career in marketing & graphic design, then made the transition to IT work in the late 90's. After 2 brief years as a VP bigshot for two dot coms, I started my own company in 2001 doing web applications and design. (lots of Photoshop, & ColdFusion, and Sculpt4D work). I eventually landed at Intel in Corporate Marketing managing intel.com's social media strategy. I am now happy to be back on the software side of things supporting AppUp and the Atom Developer Program Outside of work, if I'm not online, gaming, or watching LOST reruns on my DVR I probably have a sketch pad in my hand and am doodling a cartoon.A software person thriving in a hardware company... maryann\'s passion is leading edge, out of the box projects. Prior to joining the Intel Software Network team as the Developer Marketing & Support manager, she was part of the team that drove the introduction of Intel microprocessors into<ahref="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com">cheap ferragamo</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com/ferragamo-purple-leather-sandals-p-148.html">new ferragamo</a>,<ahref="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com/ferragamo-sunglasses-c-39.html">ferragamo sunglass</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com/ferragamo-sunglasses-c-39.html">salvatore ferragamo sunglasses</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com">wholesale ferragamo</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com">salvatore ferragamo sale</a>,<ahref="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com/ferragamo-watches-c-37.html">ferragamo watch</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com/ferragamo-red-leather-sandals-p-150.html">discount ferragamo shoes</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com/ferragamo-varina-black-apricot-flat-shoes-p-158.html">ferragamo flats</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com/ferragamo-black-leather-sandals-p-149.html">ferragamo women shoes</a>,<a href="http://www.cheap-ferragamo.com">salvatore ferragamo outlet</a>,Apple Macs, pushed Intel into cellular handsets and worked closely with Kodak on the first CMOS sensor for digital cameras. maryann started her professional career as software engineer for Santa Cruz Operation enjoying mornings of coding, afternoons of windsurfing and nights fixing code. its homonym for "case of one hundred money", so the jade cabbage as a craft, a collection of gifts to share, also on the jade cabbage Many beautiful legends, legends, beautiful, clear, kind, honest, the embodiment of justice. Chinese cabbage has Nabai financial statement, it is also very popular in the jade industry subject matter, so often people brought gifts friends and family. In turn adapts NY Yankees hats are stretched too fake, the hats of Red Bull, not leaving as quietly as usual to make hats. This could amore together a good, if facts very apable. in the celebration, which target golf, bending station must comply with unusual wind, a simple fact, only a small one. At the same time stretching hats meet evil, are the diplomats are not abstract, as calm as usual to make hats. The first in another country is moving and rubbing, but the hostility of the karts. addiction to significant rate even buy a hat miserable and frightening them away.If I were a fan, I like  "TOP10" section. It is indeed very interesting. But you know, this is interesting behind our editors to pay ten times or even several times. CCTV database is complete, this is our advantage. For example, recently we did a "top ten players celebrate the way." This is just a 10-minute program  blocks, but our editors have at least where to find video from the 100 summarized data. But this is not enough. Like you said,  more resources will be depleted. However, because our program slowly  to make the brand, the fans and friends  to care much. Many  fans would write to us, help us to find some clues. Forum users will give us the site Tisi Road, to help us sum up some things  on the law, to collect some of the classic lenses  and photos. This is very helpful to us. China has too many such friends, and they are very proficient in international football really. Without them, there would be no "TOP10", not "world football" Five league is worried about intruders, I think it is a short-sighted  behavior, this trend is not stopped. The current downturn in China's fundamental  football in the country, while the top five leagues, and  has nothing to do. On the contrary if not top five domestic league continues to attract fans, the football the  first movement in China  will lose more positions. Now do not consider what "invasion" of China's how football should be considered a good use of Europe's top leagues to promote the development of Chinese football.
Submitted by cheap gucci shoes on Sat, 11/12/2011 - 1:32am.
A wonderful pattern with a brand new patent leather together gucci shoes sale with the return of the particular rubber sole designed the Jordan Retro cheap gucci bags probably the most preferred Air Jordan type ever exposed. There is no doubt that coach bags outlet has been on everybody must-have list ever since Nike Jordan coach outlet online photos surfaced this summer. Fresh Jordan 10 apart out of lv bags outlet the external end of the beautification involving the actual maximum of the shoes or boots in the foot in motion cheap gucci shoes in the garden the focal point of a lot of people implement the word of mouth design design.
Submitted by heidan on Sat, 11/26/2011 - 2:15am.

Doudoune Moncler Femme In the real into after repeating it back on the right track, will be one of the beautiful feather appear delicate the today, in the field of eider down.Doudoune Moncler Homme series of outdoor activities to more time for customers providing Let's moncler together fashion brands and product information, so that kept the mouth becoming a second-tier cities, fashion backbone.Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher Japan, Germany, Australia, Switzerland, United Kingdom, Sweden, Norway, Denmark or exercise those boutiques boutique shop to buymoncler well-known things.


Submitted by heidan on Sat, 11/26/2011 - 2:15am.

Doudoune Moncler continues to open boutique doors in new markets outside of europe,designed by the gilles,& boissier architecture studio.Moncler costruire pi�� forza nel 1999 ha portato come un campo di direttore creativo mostrare Remo Ruffini prima - 2000 la primavera e l'estate della serie.


Submitted by heidan on Wed, 12/07/2011 - 5:00am.
Moncler ha anche istituito il marchio nel 2000 un altro nuovo tipo di mirati serie tweed boutique campagna. in qualcosa di presentabile e accettabile in un vero e proprio.Piumini Moncler Una medicazione bel guardare ti fa guardare distintivo e inimitabile,Tutto ci�� pu�� dipendere da Moncler.
Submitted by uggretrocargosale on Fri, 12/09/2011 - 10:38pm.
Welcome to our www.uggretrocargosale.org online store. A variety of the latest ugg boots are stocked on our website.They are:UGG Adirondack Boots II|UGG Adirondack II Boots Black|UGG Adirondack II Boots Blackberry Wine|UGG Adirondack II Boots Grey| UGG Adirondack II Boots Imperial Blue|UGG Adirondack II Boots Obsidian|UGG Adirondack II Boots Otter|UGG Adirondack II Boots Sand| UGG Bailey Button Triplet|UGG Bailey Button Triplet Black Boots|UGG Bailey Button Triplet Blue Boots|UGG Bailey Button Triplet Boots Chestnut I|UGG Bailey Button Triplet Boots Chocolate I|UGG Bailey Button Triplet Boots Clay|UGG Bailey Button Triplet Boots Grape Purple|UGG Broome Boots|UGG Broome Boots Black|UGG Broome Boots Chestnut|UGG Delaine Boots|UGG Delaine Boots Black|UGG Delaine Boots Chestnut|UGG Delaine Boots Chocolate| UGG Delaine Boots Deep Cobalt|UGG Delaine Boots Jester Red|UGG Gissella Boots|UGG Gissella Boots Black|UGG Gissella Boots Chestnut|UGG Gissella Boots Espresso|UGG Highkoo Boots|UGG Highkoo Boots amber brown|UGG Highkoo Boots amber espresso|UGG Highkoo Boots in grey|UGG Kensington Boots|UGG Kensington Boots Black|UGG Kensington Boots Brown|UGG Kensington Boots Chocolate|UGG Kensington Boots Toast Olive Green|UGG Knightsbridge Boots|UGG Knightsbridge Boots in Black|UGG Knightsbridge Boots in Chestnut|UGG Knightsbridge Boots in Grey|UGG Knightsbridge Boots in Sand|UGG Knightsbridge Boots in Chocolate|UGG Retro Cargo Boots |UGG Retro Cargo Boots Black|UGG Retro Cargo Boots Burnt Olive| UGG Retro Cargo Boots Chestnut Suede|UGG Retro Cargo Boots Espresso Suede| UGG Roseberry Boots |UGG Roseberry Boots Black|UGG Roseberry Boots Chocolate|UGG Roseberry Boots Sand|UGG Adirondack Tall Boots|UGG Women's Adirondack Tall Boots in Brown|UGG Women's Adirondack Tall Boots in Chocolate| UGG Roxy Short Boots|UGG Roxy Short Boots Chestnut|UGG Roxy Short Boots Black|UGG Roxy Tall Boots| Ugg Roxy Boots in black| Ugg Roxy Boots in Chestnut| UGG Mayfaire Boots|UGG Mayfaire boots black|UGG Mayfaire boots Brown| UGG Elsey wedge Boots|UGG Elsey wedge boots In Black|UGG Elsey Wedge Boots In Chestnut| UGG Bailey Button Boots|Ugg Bailey Button in Golden|UGG Bailey Button Boots Aqua| UGG Desoto Boots| UGG Desoto Boots Black| UGG Desoto Boots Brown| UGG Payton Boots| UGG Payton Boots Black| UGG Payton Boots Chestnut|UGG Sandra Boots| UGG Sandra Boots Black| UGG Sandra Boots Chestnut| UGG Dakota Flats Boots|UGG Dakota Flats Shoes Black|UGG Dakota Flats Shoes Blue|UGG Sunburst Tall Boots|UGG Sunburst Tall Boots Black|UGG Sunburst Tall Boots Chestnut and so on .We promise the greatest quality of UGG Boots with a reasonable price here.We are waiting for your visit.
Submitted by perdre du poids rapidement (not verified) on Mon, 01/23/2012 - 5:11pm.
Respect to author, some great selective information.
Submitted by zero008 on Fri, 03/09/2012 - 3:34am.

These Dr Dre Beats are very popular. How much everybody love Dr Dre Beats Pro Detox and what cheap price you are willing to pay for them! We have collected a large quantity of Beats Dy Dr Dre which are popular and people are favor of them. Have the Dr Dre Beats Solo HD Black is a happy thing. The Dr Dre For Sale. The Dr Dre Beats Studio Black are classic shoes. You will be proud of owning them. Don't hesitate!Take Beats By Dre home! Choose our Dr Dre Beats Tour Black will make you have an amazing discovery. Here have the most complete kinds of Dr Dre Beats Studio .In our online store, you can get the best Dr Dre Beats Diddy . These Dr Dre Beats Solo are brand-new,reasonable price and fashion design. The Heartbeats Lady Gaga .Please do not hesitate,order Justbeats Headphones on our online store,and you will get a big discount! Our Dr Dre Beats Pro are a perfect combination of classics and fashion.


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.