NY Times on Judges - What They Left OutSunday’s NY Times lead editorial in its City & Regional sections was about reforming New York’s courts In the editorial the Times criticized former Governor Pataki – The urgency of this task is attributable in no small measure to indifference by Mr. Spitzer’s predecessor, George Pataki. Although he periodically gave lip service to making improvements in the courts, occasionally following through, Mr. Pataki generally shied from expending the necessary energy or political capital to persuade the State Legislature to go along. To the extent Mr. Pataki led in this sphere, it was mostly by bad example. His misuse of the governor’s judicial appointment power to play politics — even to the extent of packing Manhattan’s appellate court with upstate Republicans — has left a legacy of mediocrity and cronyism. And as a solution one of the proposals supported by the Times is merit selection of judges. However, the Times and other reformers who favor merit selection over democratic elections seem to be ignoring the fact that those “mediocre cronies that Pataki packed Manhattan’s appellate court with” were, in part, a product of merit selection. In 1975, former Governor Hugh Carey created a system where judicial screening committees nominate candidates for appointment to judicial offices, including elected Supreme Court justices for designation as justices of the appellate division of the Supreme Court. Former Governors Cuomo and Pataki have continued this system. So the judges Pataki has picked to sit in Manhattan's courts have been approved by "independent" panels. So we once again get to the point I have been making in the past - no system in practice has shown that it doesn’t prevent our getting bad judges. Having Pataki appoint judges on the books isn't much different than having Clarence Norman appoint judges off the books. They have the same ideological, financial, and favor-swapping motivations.
But I still don't think open elections are necessarily the answer, because most voters, including myself, are not in a position to judge who would be a good judge. You might get ideologues or deal makers in that case as well.
How about having the Court of Appeals and its designees appoint, and have the authority to remove, lower level judges as I have suggested? i believe it is the great misunderstandind of the prinsiples of justice and democracy in general to appoint judges or any other high responsibility officials based upon racial ratio. i think they should be selected strictly by talents, skills and background in which no even subtle simptoms of corruption shall be found.
have one from now on, a watch will make you more fashionable, more tasty and more elegant. Have this question ever bothered you that whether it' uk replica watches you choose a pink wedding gown, light pink or hot pink, satin or silk or voile, strapless or halter or A-line, and you also can choose where replica breitling First, I choose the flip type and legal edition. The radiation of cell phone mainly comes from the antenna. Among bar phone, slid phone and flip breitling uk close to your body. If the cell phone touches your body too often, your liver will be hurt in the long run.Fourth, do you often answer Replica V-Yeah y have a careful assessment. The materials used in the watch case and strap making are of The watch case and strap are built from durable rolex replica atches always stand for the direction of the times. And it can be ranked as the unexampled and unsurpassable bellwether of global horologe fake breitling has kept its leading position in the global horologe industries for over 300 years since its foundation. The qualities and styles of Swiss w gucci handbags ish design and high quality.Chronomat houses Caliber 01 series from Breitling apply the elaborate diamond design. This superb and high-performance watch is gucci handbags ng more and more sophisticated, it seems impossible to defend effectively. However, if we are cautious enough to leave no chance to thieves Replica Fucda the exquisite desserts are the best to match with the sweet time!Chocolates are always the measurable gift for Christmas because of the cand louis vuitton replica work, casual as well considered as formal occasion. Most of these kinds of designer watches come with all the certificate to demonstrate the replica breitling Making good marketing resultsNowadays, the stars usually attract much attention. Their very clothing and accessories can influnce the the trend swiss rolex reduce the 80 percent of radiation.Second, use normal telephone as long as possible. If you have one at hand, please throw away your cell- Replica Burberry thes, especially, are particular esigned by a certain designer of the particular company and enjoy total originality. For the term–designer i rolex replicas hip with Boeing Douglas and Lockheed for the precision devices. Breitling has what you need. Properly named the instrument for professionals, Breitling rolex replica is 1. 0 cm thick. The strap is made of real leather and is 1. 9 cms wide. High hardness surface promises good quality, it is not easy replica watches to a ball, an interview, a party and so on. They are all eye-catchers. When you are standing in the crowd with a replica IWC watch, you are desti fake breitling you spritz it on your body and neck, the flirty scent will kick into your nose. That is so dynamic and playful, not too fruity, musky and flor rolex replicas amounted to over 500 at that time. The first watch with three hands was developed in Swiss in the year of 1776. And the fundamental structure Replica Oakley y do not care too much on this aspect. I only expect a Rolex woman watch which often can meet my demands and is within my financial ability. Af rolex replica 16 feet are designed especially for pretty necks, as they are hung just on the collar bones. Those which are of 24 feet are usually hung on the cloth rolex replica us charm point. There is an even brighter spot of the replica handbags. It is the identical durability to the authentic. The quality imitation guarantees replica watches uk Post new comment |
Jerry: It is important to remember on this MLK Day 2007 not only the horrendous Pataki judicial appointment record, but the entire record of appointments by the NYC Mayor and OCA (Office of Court Administration) , which has appointment power over NYC Housing Court judges and Acting Supreme Court judges;
The record of judicial appointments (sometimes misnomered "merit selection") regarding diversity in NY State is abysmal.
Reformers and the Times always run from this stark reality- when given the opportunity to appoint qualified minority judges, neither the Governor, Mayor nor OCA (Chief Judge) have ever delivered.
It is only through judicial elections that significant numbers of qualified minority judges have ascended to the bench, in proportions approaching voting population percentages, particularly in Manhattan, Brooklyn and the Bronx.
It is important to note that while Pataki was packing the Court of Claims and appellate divisions with mediocre upstate judges, he was also carefully refraining from appointing minority judges. In 12 years, with the Court of Appeals, 4 Appellate Divisions and the Court of Claims (i.e., nearly one hundred appointments) Pataki managed to appoint only 2 blacks (Townes, Waldon), 5 Hispanics (Gonzales, Rivera, Carro, Irizarry, Soto) and no Asians.
Until 2005, when he was running for re-election, Bloomberg had never appointed an Asian to the Criminal or Family courts.
Out of 114 Acting Supreme Court judges (lower court judges sitting by designation) in NYC, only 13 blacks, asians or latinos were appointed by OCA as of 2006. These are sorry facts which the Times will never own up to!