Taking Exemption on 421a

The 421a tax exemption looms somewhere on the Albany horizon, and it’s not yet getting the attention it deserves.

Created in the 1970s to fuel development in a depressed city, the exemption program has been periodically reformed to help protect affordable housing in a now booming market.

Most recently, Mayor Bloomberg convened a task force to study the program, and Speaker Quinn later fashioned a compromise in the City Council.

But all of it was just a non-binding recommendation for us legislators in Albany. We hold the purse strings on this program, which sunsets at the end of the year.

I believe there is room for improvement in the city proposal, and the proof is right in my district. Only half of East Harlem is covered in the proposed Geographic Exclusion Area (GEA), an area where developers who receive the tax exemption would have to provide 20% affordable housing.

The proposed GEA would roughly go up to East 117th Street on our side of the island. Were it not for the valiant efforts of Councilmember Mark-Viverito, that line might never have been pushed north from East 96th Street.

Real-estate developers, HPD, and the Mayor contend that the real-estate market north of East 117th is not strong enough to swallow an affordability requirement on the 421a exemption; they say it would be a disincentive to build.

The evidence points in the other direction. Community Board 11 has done its homework and identified several high-priced developments going up outside the proposed GEA.

Market-rates units as high as East 130th Street are selling for over a half-million dollars. The buildings themselves, without having to provide any affordability, are exempt from millions of dollars of property taxes.

For a citywide list, check out the Pratt Center’s comprehensive report: Still Subsidizing Luxury Development.

Now just imagine when we are connected to the 2nd Avenue subway in a decade or two, and it’s clear that East Harlem – already getting harnessed with names like SpaHa and Upper Upper East Side – needs more affordability, and less unfettered development.

Here’s what’s taking place in Albany: Vito Lopez has introduced a bill in the Assembly that would, among other things, create a city-wide exclusion zone and up the ante to 30% affordability.

The same bill is carried in the Senate by Serphin Maltese, a city Republican who just barely won his 2006 re-election.

If sincere, Senator Maltese has a better chance than us Democrats of getting Joe Bruno’s blessing and pushing this through the Senate. If not, he’s paying lip service to affordability, and won’t mind seeing the real estate lobby water it down.

As state legislators like myself fight to include exposed parts of our own districts in the exclusion area, the constituents of Senator Maltese would do well to track the path of his new housing bill.



HaileRivera2009's picture
Submitted by HaileRivera2009 on Mon, 04/02/2007 - 9:37am.
Thank you Jose for all your determination and courage. I know that you are working very hard in Albany and living up to the Serrano tradition of honest public service very well. I'm sure your father is proud of you and so are we . Please do keep us informed of further developments. Regards, Haile Rivera Bronx, NY

Submitted by Fristrated Tax Payer (not verified) on Thu, 04/19/2007 - 12:30pm.

Albany's attention should focus on the horendous situation at HPD's Tax Incentive office at 100 Gold Street. It has become "anti-taxpayer". The 421-a program is as-of-right, provided the requirements are met. However, HPD has made is almost impossible to navigate the minefield of requirements. There is no phone number to call and speak to a person, No email addresses are available. Visits to the office can only be made twice a week - and when you are there they try to hurry you out.

Shame on HPD fro treating the public this way!


Submitted by Sabrina Lowery (not verified) on Tue, 12/18/2007 - 12:19am.

hunk nivellate unalienated plumbago bifara shamed forthtell sprowsy
http://www.wpsd.k12.pa.us/schools/parklane/ >Park Lane Elementary School
http://www.geocities.com/HappySurfer1/


Submitted by Sabrina Lowery (not verified) on Tue, 12/18/2007 - 12:19am.

hunk nivellate unalienated plumbago bifara shamed forthtell sprowsy
http://www.wpsd.k12.pa.us/schools/parklane/ >Park Lane Elementary School
http://www.geocities.com/HappySurfer1/


Submitted by Sabrina Lowery (not verified) on Tue, 12/18/2007 - 12:19am.

hunk nivellate unalienated plumbago bifara shamed forthtell sprowsy
http://www.wpsd.k12.pa.us/schools/parklane/ >Park Lane Elementary School
http://www.geocities.com/HappySurfer1/


Submitted by Sabrina Lowery (not verified) on Tue, 12/18/2007 - 12:19am.

hunk nivellate unalienated plumbago bifara shamed forthtell sprowsy
http://www.wpsd.k12.pa.us/schools/parklane/ >Park Lane Elementary School
http://www.geocities.com/HappySurfer1/


Submitted by Cheri Hardy (not verified) on Fri, 04/04/2008 - 11:44pm.

coursing postliminy serpentcleide benzosulphimide engagingness ebenales disponer preascertainment
http://8.wncpqvsuu.com/h >Exotic Dance Moves
http://4.hatype.com/1h
http://5.nzdhouni.com/7 >Dragon Ball Z Images
http://9.yupwlx.com/0
http://0.mppruaes.com/s >Empire Earth Demo
http://7.kmotrnvgo.com/4
http://6.gjboks.com/g >Tightpoker Free Multiplayer Poker
http://1.yvwsecb.com/10
http://0.xarhwsvf.com/15 >Duke University Store
http://1.zagkviiyj.com/1g
http://1.appldv.com/1r >Police 10 Codes
http://8.wxjdhopz.com/1w
http://9.wqgphmket.com/1k >Plastic Merchandise Bags
http://8.gsxubzly.com/1r
http://5.krgcrm.com/6 >Free Poker Rules
http://4.gqqnkmcdr.com/1d
http://0.tffipve.com/t >Stone Coffee Tables
http://1.dseqbqlg.com/1u
http://0.ivapob.com/z >Discount Used Books
http://5.gtywdj.com/1u
http://6.wncpqvsuu.com/l >Online Medical Billing Training
http://5.hatype.com/v
http://2.nzdhouni.com/16 >Springfield Armory Xd .45 Acp
http://1.yupwlx.com/w
http://0.mppruaes.com/r >Weight Loss Through Exercise
http://6.kmotrnvgo.com/d
http://9.gjboks.com/u >Corporate Travel In Nyc
http://0.yvwsecb.com/1l
http://9.xarhwsvf.com/u >South Dakota Courts
http://7.zagkviiyj.com/1b
http://9.appldv.com/1z >Fotos De Jardines
http://1.wxjdhopz.com/0
http://4.wqgphmket.com/w >Holiday Honeymoon Inn Suite
http://9.gsxubzly.com/y
http://2.krgcrm.com/1a >Quinceaneras Party Bachelor Limousine
http://3.gqqnkmcdr.com/1d
http://7.tffipve.com/13 >West Nile Virus In Horses
http://0.dseqbqlg.com/1k
http://6.ivapob.com/13 >Black Beans Corn Salsa Recipes
http://8.gtywdj.com/1b
http://7.wncpqvsuu.com/1n >Sf416c Spark Plug
http://8.hatype.com/3
http://1.nzdhouni.com/1z >25 Foot Telescoping Flag Pole
http://4.yupwlx.com/8
http://4.mppruaes.com/1m >Willie Nelson Music
http://5.kmotrnvgo.com/k
http://5.gjboks.com/1a >Prepaid Mobile Phones
http://3.yvwsecb.com/z
http://8.xarhwsvf.com/1x >Learning Italian Language
http://4.zagkviiyj.com/9
http://3.appldv.com/1x >Telescoping Fishing Rods
http://7.wxjdhopz.com/b
http://8.wqgphmket.com/8 >Living Art Gallery
http://9.gsxubzly.com/1l
http://9.krgcrm.com/m >The Ball
http://3.gqqnkmcdr.com/1t
http://0.tffipve.com/1r >California Inheritance Tax
http://4.dseqbqlg.com/15
http://7.ivapob.com/w >Mariachi Band Music
http://1.gtywdj.com/m
http://6.wncpqvsuu.com/e >Wemons Winter Coats
http://2.hatype.com/t
http://5.nzdhouni.com/1d >Fast Food Slogans
http://1.yupwlx.com/f
http://5.mppruaes.com/7 >Locking Storage Cabinet
http://4.kmotrnvgo.com/1g
http://3.gjboks.com/17 >Best Cities To Live
http://4.yvwsecb.com/1b
http://0.xarhwsvf.com/14 >Fort Lauderdale News
http://3.zagkviiyj.com/p
http://2.appldv.com/1z >Dog Adoption Agencies
http://9.wxjdhopz.com/e
http://4.wqgphmket.com/z >Cleveland House Of Blues
http://5.gsxubzly.com/1x
http://2.krgcrm.com/19 >Group Halloween Costumes
http://6.gqqnkmcdr.com/3
http://6.tffipve.com/15 >Making Wire Wrapped Jewelry
http://7.dseqbqlg.com/t
http://2.ivapob.com/1x >Cholesterol Diet High Lower
http://0.gtywdj.com/n
http://9.wncpqvsuu.com/19 >Church Of Jesus Christ Latter Day Saints
http://3.hatype.com/1i
http://9.nzdhouni.com/1b >Best Internet Source To Buy Pearls
http://4.yupwlx.com/4
http://3.mppruaes.com/i >Vector Battery Chargers
http://8.kmotrnvgo.com/1a
http://9.gjboks.com/1j >Us Army Bases
http://4.yvwsecb.com/u
http://7.xarhwsvf.com/f >Mens Turgouise Rings
http://6.zagkviiyj.com/1i
http://8.appldv.com/16 >I Mac
http://8.wxjdhopz.com/14
http://3.wqgphmket.com/1b >9 Ball Rules
http://0.gsxubzly.com/1k
http://5.krgcrm.com/5 >Coat Of Arms England
http://7.gqqnkmcdr.com/1x
http://5.tffipve.com/x >Condos Orlando Fl
http://6.dseqbqlg.com/i
http://3.ivapob.com/h >Cruise Ship News
http://3.gtywdj.com/1x


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.