The Art of Government

The old saying in government is that “where you stand depends on where you sit.”

 

In other words, because I’m freshly seated as Chair of the Cultural Affairs, Tourism, Parks and Recreation Committee, it’s no wonder I stand in strong opposition to proposed budget cuts that affect, well, all of the above.

 

But the evidence is hard to ignore. The arts industry generates $25.7 billion worth of economic impact in New York State. The overall multiplier is 1.98, “which means that for every dollar in direct spending, another 98 cents of value is generated in the state’s economy.”

 

Even Milton Friedman would get pretty comfortable in a seat like that.

 

Just look at capital spending. Between 2003 and 2005, cultural institutions in New York City spent $1.4 billion on capital construction. This generated “an average of 3,460 full-time equivalent jobs in each of the three years.”

 

Yet funding for the New York State Council on the Arts could take a $7 million hit for the current fiscal year, and another $7 million for 2009-2010.

 

Meanwhile, state support for zoos, botanical gardens and aquariums would disappear under the proposed executive budget. That could mean massive layoffs at a place like the Bronx Zoo, where 38% of full-time staff and 80% of part-time staff live in the borough … and don’t forget the porcupines.

 

The point is that museums and “living museums” have always been an incubator for real growth – not the watch-my-stock-portfolio-boom kind of growth, but rather the one that produces jobs, creates linkages with local business, and expands education for our kids.

 

All the more important for our kids, who keep getting squeezed out of valuable art space in their public schools.

 

In order to restore some of these critical investments, I stand with a large number of my legislative colleagues in support of more progressive taxation. The wealthiest households in our state have taken a vacation from reality these past few decades, and must pay their fare share.

 

I will also advocate more support from the federal government – first and foremost on issues like housing and public health, but also as it relates to the arts. New Deal initiatives like the Federal Art Project and Federal Writers’ Project unleashed a great deal of hope and creativity in New York – whether it was murals (like those at WNYC) or life histories (here’s one from my own district).

 

Cultural treasures are born out of difficult times … but it often takes political will.

 

On February 3rd, Assemblymember Steve Englebright and I will convene a Joint Committee Meeting to discuss the proposed budget cuts. In the spirit of legislative reform, we are counting on bipartisan engagement and participation, and – perhaps for the first time in Albany history – soliciting YouTube commentary from organizations across the state. We want to make sure that even if you can’t make the trip to Albany – though carpooling is available! – that your voice will be heard.



Submitted by Helen (not verified) on Wed, 01/28/2009 - 10:53am.
I agree with Senator Serrano as arts are an important part in a childs life and exposure.  I'm a volunteer for Free Arts in a Charter School in the neighborhood and the children look forward to us coming every week as this is an exposure for growth.  Zoos and botanical gardens are a wonderful outlet for families and children to enjoy.
Submitted by Judith K Weiner (not verified) on Wed, 01/28/2009 - 11:06am.

Hear, Hear Senator Serrano!!!! May I add that as we see jobs in the NYS disappearing by tens of thousands, the arts employed 342,000 people in 2007-08.  And ...cultural organizations spend more than 50% of their operating budget on salaries: JOBS.

Since the arts represent less than 1/32 of 1% of the total state budget, we surely see a huge return for a tiny investment....the Senator says it so well.   


M Burgos's picture
Submitted by M Burgos on Wed, 01/28/2009 - 11:26am.

I'm all for supporting the arts, regardless of whether they generate income and taxes to help the economy, but that the fact that they do bring a respectable return on investment should certainly be enough to convince even conservatives.

But linking this to higher taxes for the wealthy? Taxing millionaires only creates new tax revenue, which supports government, and as long as medicaid fraud and other waste continues to run rampant in the state, this seems like an easy way out.

Why not work to design a tax incentive that lets higher earners be spared from the increases so long as they make a direct investment here in NY, like hiring? Why not look at the benefits of the Empire Zone project to see where else they can be applied? Why not revamp the tax code to let business that manufacture goods in NY and hire fellow New Yorkers get a benefit?

Taxing wealthy citizens more always sounds good in tough economic times but it doesn't grow an economy, it increases the tax pool. If that's the goal, seems to me that incentives to create more tax payers would have a bigger impact on the tax pool.

Or if higher taxes on the wealthy are to go towards funding the arts, why not cut the state out as the middle man and just provide incentives for the wealthy to contribute more towards the arts?

Senator Serrano, I applaud your efforts to protect the arts and recreation, but please dig a little deeper into finding a solution. Thank you.

Manny Burgos,
Brooklyn, New York
"Más vale morir luchando, que vivir muriendo."



Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 01/30/2009 - 8:15am.
for crying out loud, just cut medicaid by half, at least, and we'll be rolling in dough. 
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 11/05/2009 - 1:14am.
he art of government … which has now become the program of most governments in capitalist countries, absolutely does not seek the constitution of … [a] standardizing, mass society of consumption and spectacle, etcetera… It involves, on the contrary, obtaining a society that is not orientated towards the commodity and the uniformity of the commodity, but towards the multiplicity and differentiation of enterprises…Art Jobs and  An enterprise society and a judicial society, a society orientated towards the enterprise and a society framed by a multiplicity of judicial institutions, are two faces of a single phenomenon.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.